BlackRock loses appeal over tax on $13.5bn BGI deal

Unlock the Editor’s Digest for free

Roula Khalaf, Editor of the FT, selects her favourite stories in this weekly newsletter.

BlackRock, the world’s largest asset manager, has lost an appeal relating to tax it sought to reclaim from HM Revenue & Customs on its $13.5bn acquisition of Barclays Global Investors in 2009.

The appeal relates to a structure that was put in place by BlackRock when it bought the business from Barclays.

The US part of the BGI business was acquired through a corporate structure that included a UK tax resident entity, LLC5, which was funded by $4bn of loans from another BlackRock group entity based in the US.

The UK tax resident entity had claimed tax relief for interest costs linked to the loans, and tried to reduce the UK tax bills of other, profitable companies in the BlackRock group by setting the resulting tax losses against their profits.

The Court of Appeal decision handed down on Thursday is the culmination of a years-long dispute.

HMRC originally rejected the tax deductions, before the First-tier Tribunal found in BlackRock’s favour. That decision was reversed on appeal to the Upper Tribunal, and upheld by the Court of Appeal, albeit on different grounds.

The Court of Appeal found that the tax deductions for the interest on the loans were disallowed under the “unallowable purpose rule”. It concluded that, in becoming a party to the loans, LLC5 had a main purpose of obtaining a tax advantage.

BlackRock said it had “paid all of its UK corporation tax, including the payment some time ago of all tax due in relation to this matter”, and that the “purpose of this hearing relates to the operation of a specific point of tax law”.

The asset manager added that it was “closely evaluating our next steps”.